Since I seem to be varying from my standard format, I'll sneak in this post. I ran across a pair of Harry Potter reviews from earlier this year that address two opposing Catholic viewpoints of the books. Unsurprisingly, I completely agree with the positive essay by Paolo Gulisano, which talks about the book's emphasis of weakness over strength and the central theme of death and what lies beyond. I was somewhat startled, however, to find that although the final conclusion was flawed, the negative essay by Edoardo Rialti rose to meet the story on its own terms and made several good points along the way.
Ironically, both essays use Tolkien and Lewis as the epitome of excellent fantasy, but while Rialti claims that "There is no hero more antithetical to Harry Potter than Tolkien’s young man Frodo", Gulisano points out that Rowling's use of small (or sometimes very large) acts by unlikely characters is very reminiscent of Tolkien. Gulisano wins the point in that debate, I'd say. Harry was always meant to be more of an Aragorn than a Frodo anyway, both were laden with more destiny than they knew what to do with.
However, if we're going to pick at how Rowling falls short of the Tolkien ideal (not just LOTR, but Tolkien's definition of a transcendent story, see "On Fairy Stories"), I would say the real problem is that the magical world of Hogwarts and wizards was not far enough removed from the real world. The purpose of fantasy is not to frown upon real life, but to see the magic that is already there. Because we kept running into the Durselys and the likes of the muggle Prime Minister or the Riddles, anything muggle comes across as ridiculous or tedious, despite all the main characters' defense of the non-wizarding world.
This not-quite-separation is the real cause of what Rialti calls "a deep and serious lie, the . . . . temptation of joining salvation and the truth with a secret knowledge". It is not the magic itself that causes the problem, but its placement so close to the mundane world. In fact, the main problem I have with Rialti's essay is that he over-emphasizes the significance of magic in the overall theme of the story. He claims that the real heart of the story is witchcraft: "proposed as a positive ideal; violent manipulation of things and persons thanks to occult knowledge . . . . the ends justifies the means, since the wise, the chosen, the intellectual know how to control the dark powers and turn them into good". I found this claim to be interesting because Rialti is describing a real, tangible danger. Tolkien called it a "morbid illusion" and Lewis a "spiritual lust", but it basically boils down to the same thing--a desire for secret knowledge, for elevation above the masses that was once embodied by alchemy and sorcery, but can be built on anything from new-age spirituality to science or even selective faces of religion.
The fundamental problem here is that Harry's magic is not gained through occult knowledge or a pact with dark forces, it's simply a talent that certain people are born with. If you are not born a wizard, no amount of study or knowledge will change that, and even with no knowledge of magic whatsoever, it is possible to perform it. The inclusion of the non-magical world is a flaw that opens the door to the real danger that Rialti warns of, but not a fatal flaw because of the way it's handled throughout the story. In the world Rowling created, magic is a plot tool and a hook for the real story of love and self-giving that follows it.
I once knew a boy who really, truly thought that magic could give him power. He had a very difficult home life, was bullied or excluded at school, and thought that a circle of salt or the right words said at midnight on a full moon would give him the control and revenge that he so desperately wanted. In between other attempts to dissuade him, I tried to get him to read the Harry Potter books, thinking that the magic would interest him enough to pick up on the story's deeper, more valuable lessons--but he wasn't interested in the slightest. There was nothing he could use in those books, nothing that fed his desire for secret knowledge and power. Any time someone mentions how dangerous the Harry Potter books are, I think of him, and how much good it might have done him to read them.
Labels: fantasy, Harry Potter
Yay, the pretty is back! (knock on wood, I still don't know what was wrong in the first place)
The layout isn't perfect (don't bother clicking on the tabs, for instance, they don't go anywhere yet) but hopefully tomorrow I'll actually post something substantial :-p
Labels: Not review
Grrr, I apologize for the weird format. I'm not sure what's wrong, and I don't really have the time or energy to fix it right now :-p Hopefully I can bring the prettiness back soon.
Labels: Not review
I was at the library a few weeks ago and just happened to stumble upon the novelization of the Iron Man movie. I was unenthusiastic at first--a novel based on a movie based on a comic--there's only so many iterations a story can go through before it runs out of steam. But I picked it up anyway, read through a few paragraphs, and remembered that I really liked the movie, had wanted to see it a second time, but probably wasn't ever going to get around to it. So, with nothing to loose but a few hours of my time, I took the book home with me ^_^
Overview
It turned out to be basically a line-by-line retelling of the movie. Tony Stark is a genius weapons designer who idealistically believes that his weapons are only hurting bad guys until he gets kidnapped by terrorists who used his own weapons against American troops. Tony then does some serious re-thinking of the universe. This re-thinking involves, among other things, the creation of a mechanized suit of armor with incredible destructive and defensive capabilities, which he uses to convince the terrorists of the error of their ways. (Or maybe he blows them all up, one of the two)
Recommended for: Meh. The movie was excellent, (you should really see it if you haven't already) and I'm assuming the original comics are also pretty good. I can't really recommend the book, though. Maybe if you need an extra dose of Iron Man, or you really want to know what's going on but can't get your hands on either the movie or the comic.
Parental Worries: The movie was PG-13, and that fits the book as well. Tony is a playboy who likes his liquor, and people get blown up, shot, and otherwise roughed about in traditional action-movie style.
Ramblings
Don't get me wrong--I did enjoy the book, but only because I'd enjoyed the movie and was able to play it back in my head. The novelization was not all that great. There's literally only two, maybe three places where you pick up information that wasn't available in the movie, and for the most part they're either obvious or inconsequential. Everything else is a straight re-write of the script. There are some novelizations that add significantly to a movie, but this wasn't really one of them. For example, I thought the novels for the first two Star Wars prequels were vastly better than their movies, although Iron Man was a much better movie, so maybe that's an unfair comparison.
One more beef before I sign off--all of the action scenes in the book were written in italics, as if we couldn't figure out that a change in POV had taken place. That's entire pages written in italics, which gets old really fast.
I finally decided that it was time to pick up Tales of the Otori again--time to grow up and get over my disappointment from the last book I'd read. Grass for His Pillow turned out to be less intense than the first two books, with no major surprises or twists. There's still a fair amount of action, tragedy, etc, but this volume is suffering from the 'middle of a trilogy' effect. (despite the fact that there's five books in the series :-p)
Overview (Spoiler Threat: Moderate)
It's hard to give a summary of the middle book without giving away some of the earlier books, so if you care about spoilers, it's probably a good idea to skip this whole review and just check out the review for Heaven's Net is Wide.
When we left off, Evil Overlord was dead and Beautiful Not-a-Maiden-Anymore was left heartbroken because Lonely Emo Hero had to go pursue his destiny.
Okay, that's an unfair simplification, but only kind of. Luckily, Takeo quickly regrets his decision to join the Tribe, sticking around just long enough to learn a few more crazy ninja skills. Unluckily, this poor kid has a triple helping of destiny, so he's still got to restore the Otori clan and save the Hidden (or do something for the Hidden, it's not quite clear). Meanwhile, Kaede picks up some character development as she works to hold onto her father's lands and claim the much large domain she inherited from her aunt. (confused yet? yeah, I don't know if it's a good idea to review individual books that fall in the middle of a series)
Recommended for: Fantasy fans and anime fans, but only if you've read the first two books, don't start here.
Parental Worries: Less sex and violence than the first books, but there's still a fair amount of both.
Audiobook Comments: Read by Kevin Gray and Aiko Nakasone, who do a very good job.
Ramblings (Spoiler Threat: Low)
I feel like a bit of a hypocrite, because I complained so much about the plot twists in Across the Nightingale Floor, and now that we have a nice calm book that's basically all exposition, I'm criticizing that too. In fact it was so calm, and things were going so well for the heroes, that when I looked down to discover there were only 30 minutes left in the book, my automatic thought was 'Okay, just enough time for the shit to hit the fan and leave us hanging for the next book'. But no, we sailed smoothly through the last 30 minutes. We're promised shit hitting the fan as soon as the next story starts, but that's in the future. (and I am learning not to trust Hearn's promises, anyway) The ending of this book is actually quite happy ^_^ I approve.
All in all though, I've got to admit that I'm not really reading these books for their plot or their characters. Both are interesting and likeable, but frustrating and occasionally annoying at the same time. I'm really reading these books for the beautiful setting that Hearn paints, the oriental aesthetic that pervades the entire series. For authenticity, I'd be better off reading the ancient Chinese and Japanese classics, but the Tales of the Otori are much more accessible (in several different senses of the word) and it's not like I'm cultured enough to know the difference ^_~
Labels: fantasy, Tales of the Otori
Men at Arms was the first Discworld book I read that actually belonged to a continuing character arc, so I've always considered it to be a flagship of the series. It's not a bad place to start, either, since several new characters are introduced and the old ones are expanded upon, but there's not so much backstory that the reader gets lost. It's an excellent book, both on its own and as part of the series.
Overview
Affirmative action has come to Ankh-Morpork, but because this is Discworld, the Watch's new minority hires consist of a dwarf, a troll, and a . . . well, women aren't technically a minority, but everyone assumes that's the group Lance-Corporal Angua is representing. Captain Vimes is not thrilled with the new arrangement, but since he will shortly be married and retired, he figures it's not his problem.
Meanwhile, the young assassin Edward d'Eath, outraged at his family's fall into poverty and obscurity and increasingly obsessed with ancient royalty, thinks he has discovered the long-lost heir to the throne of Ankh-Morpork and plots to put him back in his rightful place. A half-crazed assassin shouldn't have been too much trouble, but Edward manages to get his hands on a strange new weapon that gives him incredible power--the gonne. In a world where the crossbow is the height of weapons technology, even a single firearm can cause quite a bit of trouble, especially since this one seems to have a mind of its own.
Other topics on the table for your enjoyment include clowns, dogs, monarchy, the properties of springs and the superconductivity of silicon. They all fit together, I promise.
Recommended for: Everyone. You don't have a good enough excuse not to.
Parental Worries: As before, these books are written for adults, but the target audience mostly comes through in the jokes. Unlike most Discworld books, there is some sex, but never actually 'on screen' as it were. You can figure out what happens, but they don't spell out any details.
Audiobooks: Read by the amazing Nigel Planer, who takes the already colorful characters into a whole new dimension.
Ramblings (Spoiler Threat: Low)
One of the reasons I'm particularly fond of this book is that Carrot and Vimes are both over the growing pains from their first novel. Carrot is no longer the green kid that arrested the leader of the Thieves Guild--he's solid gold, and so is everything he touches from here on out. It would be annoying, if he didn't make up for it by being embarrassingly earnest and completely hopeless at anything involving subterfuge. Vimes is . . . well, I can't say he's entirely reformed his ways, 'cause that's half his charm, but he's definitely benefited from having Sybil to look after him, and this book is where he really starts moving up in the world. (kicking and screaming all the way, but moving up nonetheless ^_~ )
I can't decide what Pratchett is trying to say (if anything) about gun control in general, because the circumstances in the story don't really apply to anything in the real world today. (One gun in the world vs. a world full of guns) He makes a couple of points that seem to be ridiculing bits of gun rights activism, but Pratchett is too smart to suggest that all guns should be illegal, he actually makes a point in another book about the stupidity of outlawing all weapons, so that only criminals are armed. I doubt it's even an issue in Britain, so the gonne may just be a convenient plot device, and not a social commentary :-p
Quotes Time!
"'There's stranger people in this world than Corporal Nobbs, my lad.'
Carrot's expression slid into a rictus of intrigued horror.
'Gosh.'"
"There were such things as Dwarf gods (...) they'd seen the need for gods as a sort of supernatural equivalent of a hard hat. Besides, when you hit your thumb with an eight-pound hammer it's nice to be able to blaspheme. It takes a very special and strong minded kind of atheist to jump up and down with their hand clasped under their other armpit and shout, 'Oh, random-fluctuations-in-the-space-time-coninuum!' or 'Aaargh, primitive-and-out-moded-concept on a crutch!'"
"Dwarfs are very attached to gold. Any highwayman demanding ‘Your money or your life’ had better bring a folding chair and packed lunch and a book to read while the debate goes on."
"But the thing was that good boots lasted for years and years. A man who could afford fifty dollars had a pair of boots that’d still be keeping his feet dry in ten years’ time, while a poor man who could only afford cheap boots would have spent a hundred dollars on boots in the same time and would still have wet feet."
--Captain Samuel Vimes ‘Boots’ theory of socio-economic unfairness.
"‘Coalface? In the Watch?’
Dink. ‘Corporal Carrot says there’s some good buried somewhere in everyone,’ said Detritus.
‘And what’s your job, Detritus?’
Dink. ‘Engineer in charge of deep mining operations, sah!’"
"Sometimes it's better to light a flamethrower than curse the darkness."
I'd heard quite a bit about the Song of Ice and Fire series by George R.R. Martin before I actually steeled myself to read it, and what I'd heard justified the use of the word 'steeled'. 'Wonderful story!' they said 'epic and complex, with such real characters! But very dark, lots of violence and sex, very gritty!' (I like that word, gritty, for these novels--think Frank Miller does fantasy)
Overview
Surprisingly enough, they were right. I went into the book expecting to dislike it, because it was obviously setting itself up as Lord of the Rings all grown up. (Seriously, look at the author's name! Even if your middle initials are actually 'R.R.', it still screams "I'm just like Tolkien, see my epic fantasy skillz!") And any story that employs graphic sex and violence to get its point across must be lacking in basic narrative, right? But to my mild surprise, it didn't take long to get so deeply wrapped up in the story that I didn't mind the dark bits. Actually, my expectations of darkness and death led to a couple of nice surprises when characters survived after I'd written them off as dead.
Anyway, on to the summary: Due to some magical mishap back in the mists of time, the natural course of the seasons has slowed, leading to summers and winters that last anywhere from two to ten years. Currently, the land is experiencing a summer that has lasted a decade, but it is coming to an end, and a long summer always means a long winter to follow. Into this setting of approaching doom, we follow (mostly) the Stark family, an ancient line that has always lived at the northernmost tip of civilization, first and last to face the long winters. Currently, the family consists of Ned Stark, his wife Catelyn and their 5 children, plus a bastard son who is only occasionally treated as anything but fully legitimate. The children are fairly young, ranging from 15 to 3, and part of the book's darkness is that these children are major players in its terrible events.
Ned Stark is fully content to stay in his ancestral home and prepare his family and lands for the coming winter, but a summons from the King to serve him at court tears Ned away from his life of peace, entangling him in the dangerous game of thrones, where you either win, or you die.
Recommended for: Fantasy fans ready for a commitment, and historical fiction fans willing to try something new.
Parental Worries: Gosh, where do I start? Incest, statutory rape, disembowelings, demonic forces, on and on. If you made a list of the things you don't want your kids reading about, you'd probably find 95% of them in this book and (I would assume) its sequels.
Audiobook Comments: Read by Roy Dotrice, who does a very good job. Thinking back on the book, I was under the impression that they had a female reader to do the female POVs, which is both a strong compliment to his skills and a sign that I'm still channeling Tales of the Otori.
Ramblings (Spoiler Threat: Low)
I have to grimace at that summary, because I'm pretty sure several lines of it are ripped straight from the back of the book. Unfortunately, it'd be really hard to summarize it any other way in less than 3 pages. I could go into the many different warring factions, the reasons for the throne's instability in the first place, and the completely separate but sinister albino Morgul-wraiths sweeping down from the winterlands, but really, at that point it's just easier to read the book. I will say though, that Thrones keeps up with its complex plot very well. Its many branches threaten to overwhelm the reader from time to time, but it manages to keep us afloat.
Martin has created a lush, beautiful world complete with history and at least a basic mythology (although he's got at least three more books to build with, there's plenty of room to expand both). He escapes many fantasy cliches by making everyone human, and in fact this first installment reads more like historical fiction than fantasy, with only a few fantastic bits, mostly at the beginning and end of the book.
One of the things I find frustrating about Thrones is that in the end, there is no clear 'evil' side. That's going to be a plus for many readers, but although I have no problem with complex characters and sympathetic antagonists, I do like to at least have a side to cheer for. I honestly liked at least one member of, and occasionally hoped for the success of, each of the three major factions in the game of thrones. Each side has its villians and champions. Nothing is clear cut, all exists as shades of gray. The balance and internal conflict it creates speaks of great skill on the author's part, but what it gains in interest and impressiveness, it loses in pure, deep-seated satisfaction. So overall, the series is promising and impressive, but anyone who considers Martin to be Tolkien's successor has been reading the wrong genre.
Labels: fantasy, Song of Ice and Fire